Look up for a Change

Why so serious?

Archive for May 28th, 2009

Comcast Fair Usage Policy!

Posted by boddhayan on May 28, 2009

Karl Bode over on DSL Reports reports that Comcast will institute a 250 GB cap on its broadband connections starting Oct. 1. Expect other carriers to follow suit and make tiered broadband a reality. Much as I would like to think otherwise, this is the end of the Internet as we know it.

The caps are a move to ensure that the gouging scheme put in place by Comcast and other cable providers stays intact and they can continue to sell their video-on-demand services. It was a point I made when I wrote, Why Tiered Broadband Is The Enemy of Innovation. I will say this again: this is to stymie services like Hulu, NetFlix and Amazon On-Demand.

In yet another post, I thought of this as a nicer way of getting around net neutrality issues. I just don’t buy Comcast’s arguments, which smell like urine on a hot summer day.

Comcast’s arguments about infrastructure and bandwidth costs and so on are sort of hollow as some of the experts in our comments had indicated. On its network management web site, Comcast uses examples of some services and what you can do with the 250 GB limit.

250 GB per month is an extremely large amount of data, much more than a typical residential customer uses on a monthly basis. Currently, the median monthly data usage by our residential customers is approximately 2 – 3 GB. To put 250 GB of monthly usage in perspective, a customer would have to do any one of the following:

* Send 50 million emails (at 0.05 KB/email)
* Download 62,500 songs (at 4 MB/song)
* Download 125 standard-definition movies (at 2 GB/movie)
* Upload 25,000 hi-resolution digital photos (at 10 MB/photo)

Now, if you put it in terms of HD video, 250 GB doesn’t really add up to much. I did the math in an earlier post.

… we’re moving towards HD downloads. With HD, each roughly two-hour-long movie is going to consume about 8 GB, while live sports events, etc., when watched in higher quality can take up some 13 GB. Remember, we share our Internet connections with multiple people in a household. So, before you know it, that 250 GB isn’t enough.

If the company essentially thinks that 250 GB is a lot of bandwidth, then why impose a cap at all? After all, their CTO claimed in an interview with Stacey that an average consumer takes up about 2 GB of data transfer every month. I think they are being typical Comcast — indulging in selective truths.

Read the Source

Posted in Info | Tagged: , , , | Leave a Comment »

Airtel Fair Usage Policy!

Posted by boddhayan on May 28, 2009

Airtel Fair Usage policy has become the latest nightmare for the customers of Airtel Broadband. We have always believed Airtel to be different from other ISPs in the country. They have always charged a premium. But anyone who moved to Airtel from a competing provider would tell you that it is totally worth it.

The customer support is so awesome that you are amazed that it works as they promise. Speeds are as per the plans. Everything feels just right with Airtel Broadband.

But things are apparently changing. Airtel is doing a Comcast with us. They have decided to implement their own Airtel Fair Use Policy on us. This means that the company is enforcing data transfer limits on their supposedly unlimited plans. If you consume too much bandwidth in a month, they reserve the right to slow down your speeds.

And if they did not inform you about it first, the customer care people would apologize and pass on the message.
What can you do? Maybe write some emails to Airtel management, maybe to the TRAI. It’s unlikely to do anything this time around. Because no one cares about the so called ‘broadband revolution’ that was supposed to happen in India ever since we landed on the ‘information superhighway’.

FUP

Read the source

Posted in Review | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

So how fair is Fair Usage Policy of Broadband?

Posted by boddhayan on May 28, 2009

Have you signed up for an “unlimited” package only to read the small print and find out that your broadband can be capped? Almost every company that sells “unlimited” broadband actually has a fair usage policy, which can end up imposing limits on your downloading or throttling your download speed.

If you are one of the millions of people who download music, movies and high resolution photos, then this could affect to you. While you might not be downloading anything like 20GB or 40GB a month now, the rise of film downloads, internet television and popular legal peer-to-peer networks like the BBC iPlayer are all set to massively increase the amount we download.

What to look out for

Put simply, fair usage is the broadband industry’s attempt at keeping cyber traffic down. The policy was designed to protect the people who might be affected by your downloading.

You probably share your broadband connection with around 49 other people because most home broadband connections have a contention ratio of 50:1.

So the problem is that if you’re a big downloader, you could be slowing down the broadband connection of up to 49 other people. And if you are regularly affecting other people’s internet, your ISP might decide that something needs to be done.

It’s when you use it, not how

Your ISP is only trying to ensure that everyone has a good user experience. Those most likely to be affected by a fair usage policy are:

  • Users of peer-to-peer networks uploading and downloading lots of films and music
  • Online gamers
  • People working from home and remotely connecting to the office
  • Any other heavy downloader’s

If any of these apply to you, try cutting down your internet usage, or try downloading in the small hours when less people will be online in your street. That way you can still download as much as you want, without causing problems for anyone else.

Typical penalties

Most ISPs will ignore over-sized downloading for a month or two, and will then get in touch asking that you curb your usage. If, however, you continue to exceed the limits they are likely to take action.

This could take the form of reducing the speed of your connection, therefore limiting the amount that can be downloaded; restricting your usage at peak times; charging you for your excess usage; or restricting your use of peer-to-peer sites.

In extreme cases, they even might terminate your contract, cutting off your internet until you can get a new connection.

If, having signed up for an “unlimited” package, and anything like this does happen, but you don’t think you’ve been excessively downloading, there is something you can do.

Traffic management

Lots of broadband providers now use traffic shaping as a way of controlling users’ downloads during peak hours, which is another reason to set your PC to download over night when your speed is less likely to be throttled.

Dispute and resolution

After trying to resolve the issue with your ISP you could get in touch with Otelo, the telecommunication industry’s watchdog, whose job it is to investigate complaints by customers. Otelo also charges its members for being investigated so it will help your case to get them involved.

The majority of providers are Otelo members, but if yours isn’t, try Ofcom, the independent regulator for the UK, who should still be able to help (see useful links).

Why not tell us your download horror stories? Maybe we can help. tellusyourstory@broadbandchoices.co.uk

How do I keep track of my monthly downloads?

Keeping an eye on your downloads can be difficult and becomes a particular problem if you have a wireless network and use more than one computer on the same broadband connection. Thankfully, you can install our free Broadband Download Monitor, which not only allows you to keep track of how much you download, but also lets you set warnings to avoid exceeding limits.

“I have to face facts; I’m a download-a-holic”

If you know that you’re a big downloader, it might simply be time to admit that you need to cut down.

But what counts as a big download? The average single song MP3 is about 5Mb, while a DVD quality movie is 4GB (Ofcom, 2007). So if you’re downloading 10 DVD quality movies every month, plus surfing the internet, downloading music and uploading pictures to social networking sites like Facebook and MySpace, the chances are that you’ll be exceeding your fair usage policy.

You need to be realistic – if you are doing a lot of downloading, you need a beefy package. It saves on the aggravation and will mean that you won’t have your broadband throttled to curb your habits.

So what is the right package?

Why go through the hassle of a fair usage deal and risk incurring the wrath of your ISP when you exceed your limit? Try a high end package with a generous download limit and no peak-time traffic shaping.

Alternatively, if you still want to keep costs down, try Sky Broadband (www.Sky.com). It has recently removed the fair usage restrictions from its Max Broadband package, making it the only unrestricted, affordable, consumer broadband package on offer at the moment.

Compare broadband packages in your area, sort by price and check notes the notes for any restrictions.

Fair usage deals

There’s nothing wrong with fair usage deals, but you need to be careful and keep an eye on your downloading, and if your provider doesn’t publish the limits of its fair usage policy, be careful as you won’t know when to stop.

Read the source

Posted in Review | Tagged: , , , | 1 Comment »